
I’m With You is one of the best additions to the Red Hot Chili Peppers’ body of work. This is about the last thing I would have foreseen writing when I had heard that they were again going to be releasing a Fruscianteless album. To be plainly honest, I think John Frusciante is one of the greatest guitarists of our generation, and is probably my favourite. For me it was hard to anticipate the new album without him with anything but foreboding. Perhaps it’s because of this that I’m so utterly satisfied with what they’ve released, but I think it’s gone beyond that. This isn’t just a case of minimalist expectations being exceeded. This is a legitimately superb Chili Peppers album by any standards. I never expected to say this, but I would place this album as the best thing they’ve written since Californication. Stadium Arcadium is good… but I have my issues with it. In all seriousness, very few bands can pull off a double album, and honestly they don’t really have to. I don’t need thirty songs. I would be happier with the top fifteen. The Peppers have a bit of range to their music, but not enough for me to want to listen to them for two hours. Mellon Collie and the Infinite Sadness is probably one of the only double albums I can think of that was actually necessary. The Pumpkins were a different band than the Peppers though. They had a range to their sound that bordered on ridiculous. The same band wrote 1979, Fuck You (An Ode to No One), and Tonight Tonight… and put them on the same album. Without that musical diversity though, an album can become tired if it’s too long. The Peppers have two sounds… fast and slow. It’s not a bad thing. It’s normal.
I had originally expected to be disappointed with the album unless the Peppers had managed to replace John with someone equally as talented and unique, but I’m surprised to say that I think it’s because they didn’t that this album is such a success. Their new guitarist Josh Klinghoffer is messy. Frusciante was one of the tightest, most precise, and cleanest sounding musicians out there. Just listen to Under the Bridge, or Snow, or Scar Tissue (or essentially anything else the band released before I’m With You) and you can hear that there’s never a note that isn’t perfectly timed. Everything is clean. There’s never an accidental string hit, a vibration left too long, or a dead string anywhere there shouldn’t be. Frusciante was comparable to a photo realist painter with his guitar. Klinghoffer would be an Impressionist. This isn’t an insult by the way. It’s a stylistic difference. Klinghoffer probably doesn’t aim to play with the same pristine precision. That’s not his sound, and it’s not because of a lack of skill. The greatest guitarist of all time was a sloppy guitarist… I’ll let you figure that one out on your own. What makes it surprising that he fits so well, however, is that the Chili Peppers as a band has always been a very clean band. Chad Smith is a surprisingly well regarded drummer in drum circles (bad pun is bad), Kiedis is known for his fast rap like singing style that is choppy but enunciated, and Flea is fucking Flea.

Speaking of Flea, this is why this album is so good. If I had to guess, I would say that the absence of Frusciante on the album has left it open for every song to be built around his talents as opposed to him normally playing behind the guitar riffs. It almost seems that I’m With You is Flea’s baby. About seventy five percent or more of the album is lead by him and Klinghoffer clearly writing a lot of his music to fit with what Flea is doing. Everyone has always known that despite being in the background usually, Flea was probably the most technically talented member of the band, and it’s mostly because of his ability to shine despite being in the shadows musically. If you want an example of what I’m talking about, go to the 3:30 mark of Love Rollercoaster and listen to the faint (funky as fuck) solo Flea busts out that probably about half of you never even noticed was there, but will probably become the reason you listen to the song from now on.
So let me get to the actual album of I’m With You. The Adventures of Rain Dance Maggie is probably among my least favourite of the new songs, despite it being the single, and despite it being an alright Chili Peppers song regardless. This is generally the mark of a good CD. The single is the song that they expect everyone to like. Anything that you will truly love generally won’t be something that has a mass appeal associated with it. Think about your favourite song by your favourite band. Is it one of their singles? I doubt it. (After typing this, I started thinking of the Chili Peppers and realized that everything off of Blood Sex Sugar Magik, and Californication single wise is incredible… but I swear it works for pretty much any other band) But I digress, as usual.
The first song you’ll hear will be Monarchy of Roses. It sets the tone perfectly. Jamming drums and bass, sloppy guitar, and then kicks in with a classic Chili Peppers chorus with Flea taking the lead.
Factory of Faith is next. This feels like old Peppers. Kiedis is right on top of his classic vocal style, and Flea’s bass line is nice and funksational. I’m going to need to describe Flea a lot I’ve realized, and have decided I’m going to need to think of different variations of funky to keep myself from sounding repetitive. The bridge of this song is awesome. The transition back into the chorus feels good. In fact the transitions are generally done in very interesting ways throughout the album. They also give Klinghoffer his opportunity to break out a little at the end and he has a really nice and terrifunk (that’s terrific, not terrible) solo.
Next is probably my favourite song currently. Brendan’s Death Song. They slow it down, and Kiedis actually sounds fairly un-Kiedis-ish on this one, and it’s not a bad thing. His melody is just awesome. This would be a perfect song to finish off a concert with, and I fully intend on seeing them for their tour, and I fully expect them to do so.
Ethiopia is pretty standard. After that is Annie Wants a Baby which is slowed down Peppers once again. I love the ending… but I can’t put my finger on why. It just works nicely.
Look around comes after and it’s a solid high energy song. You have a few good, not great, by no mean bad, songs next (I should note that Goodbye Hooray is funking good - awesome pun is awesome) until you get to Happiness Loves Company. It’s not often you hear a piano in a Peppers song, but you will here, a few times actually throughout the end of the CD.
I think this is where I started to notice how much the band has matured. Their sounds has clearly mellowed, but it’s aged nicely. They don’t sound like a bunch of old men trying to be twenty year old rock stars. They know what they do well, and they execute it, but aren’t stuck in a repetitive cookie cutter sound. This isn’t just an album aimed to please fans by playing it safe and sticking to basics. They’ve adjusted parts of their sound in places like any band should do, but also have retained that very distinct Chili Peppers sound that so many people want to hear from them. I don’t think there will be many fans disappointed with what they get when they listen to it today. It’s not Blood Sex, and it’s not Californication, but it’s unfair to judge a band based on that standard. Both of those albums were generally agreed to be among the best of their generation. If you can listen to I’m With You without comparing it to the band’s greatest success, I’m sure you’re going to be pleasantly surprised by what you receive. Enjoy.

Rock on boys.